DST Due Diligence Lab • How I Look at a Transaction
By Al DiNicola, AIF®
VP, Investment Property Wealth Management®
Realized Financial, Inc
Co-author, DST Wealth Building
Editor, DSTNews.org
I do not believe that a fee is automatically unreasonable simply because it exists. A real estate transaction requires professionals, systems and ongoing oversight. My concern is whether each fee is understandable, competitively supportable and appropriately aligned with investor interests.
Distinguish closing costs from compensation
Harbor Point’s $2 million acquisition, financing and offering expense pool is not necessarily $2 million of compensation. It could include lender charges, legal counsel and title services alongside sponsor and placement compensation. I would separate third-party charges from affiliated compensation and ask whether there are related-party reimbursements. The recipient and purpose matter as much as the label.
Find the recurring costs
Our illustrative property generates $2.4 million of NOI. After $1.1 million in interest-only payments at 5.5% on $20 million of debt and an assumed $230,000 of asset-management and administrative expenses below NOI, $1.07 million remains before distributions and contingencies. This example assumes property-management expenses are already reflected in property operating costs used to calculate NOI; counting them twice would be misleading. Real offering definitions must be checked.
Examine fees on the way out
What happens when the building sells? A disposition fee, broker commission, affiliate participation or other sale expense may reduce proceeds. Are fees based on gross sale price, net equity or something else? Could someone be paid even if investors lose money? The answers can change incentives and investor outcomes.
Compare like with like
One sponsor may quote acquisition fees alone; another may aggregate transaction and financing costs. I would build a consistent matrix listing each fee, calculation basis, recipient, timing and whether it is related-party compensation. Then I would evaluate the sponsor’s actual responsibilities and investor reporting alongside the dollar amounts.
Al’s due diligence perspective
The question I try to answer is not, ‘Which offering advertises the lowest fees?’ It is, ‘What am I paying, what value is being provided, and how do these costs influence my return and risk?’
Next: Article 5 — Cap Rate vs. Distribution Rate — They Are Not the Same
Important Disclosures: This material is for informational purposes only and does not constitute an offer to sell or solicitation to purchase securities. DST investments involve risks, including limited liquidity, loss of principal, and non-guaranteed distributions. Investors should consult their tax, legal, and financial advisers. Investment advisory services offered through Fiduciary Capital Management LLC, an SEC-registered investment adviser. Securities offered through Realized Financial, Inc., Member FINRA/SIPC. Fiduciary Capital Management is a separate registered investment advisory firm and is not a subsidiary of Realized Financial, Inc., or Realized.
