What Happens If a DST Underperforms? A Realistic Guide for Investors

Delaware Statu­to­ry Trusts (DSTs) are often mar­ket­ed as sta­ble, pas­sive real estate invest­ments. How­ev­er, no invest­ment is immune to chal­lenges. Over the past few years there have been chal­lenges with many real estate invest­ments as well as DSTs.

May 20, 2026

By Al DiNi­co­la, AIF®
Fund Advi­sor
DST 1031 Spe­cial­ist
Fidu­cia­ry Cap­i­tal Man­age­ment, LLC
Secu­ri­ties offered through MSC-BD, LLC, Mem­ber of FINRA/SIPC

Intro­duc­tion

Even well-struc­tured DSTs can under­per­form due to mar­ket con­di­tions, ten­ant issues, or finan­cial fac­tors. Under­stand­ing DST under­per­for­mance is crit­i­cal so you can set real­is­tic expec­ta­tions, pro­tect your cap­i­tal, and avoid sur­pris­es. We have writ­ten in anoth­er arti­cle about how impor­tant the spon­sor is and why con­duct­ing due dili­gence is impor­tant.

In this guide, we’ll break down a few items includ­ing why DSTs under­per­form and what hap­pens when they do. We will also dive into how it impacts your income and prin­ci­pal. What may be most impor­tant is how to man­age and mit­i­gate risk.

What Does DST Under­per­for­mance Mean?

There are many fac­tors that may be an indi­ca­tor of under­per­for­mance. A DST is con­sid­ered to be under­per­form­ing when it fails to meet its pro­ject­ed cash flow dis­tri­b­u­tions. Cash flows are always stat­ed as pro­ject­ed and giv­en an illus­tra­tion of items in a pro­for­ma typ­i­cal­ly found in the Pri­vate Place­ment Pro­for­ma (PPM).  Pro­for­mas are struc­tures with a cer­tain occu­pan­cy lev­el (if a mul­ti­fam­i­ly prop­er­ty for exam­ple). There are also poten­tial appre­ci­a­tion tar­gets.  The exit price expec­ta­tions are based on the Net Oper­at­ing income with a mar­ket cap­i­tal­iza­tion Rate (Cap Rate) as a mul­ti­pli­er.

Not achiev­ing the pro­ject­ed dis­tri­b­u­tions or occu­pan­cy does not nec­es­sar­i­ly mean the invest­ment is fail­ing. It means results are below ini­tial pro­jec­tions.

Inter­nal Link:
“What Is a Delaware Statu­to­ry Trust (DST)?”

Com­mon Caus­es of DST Under­per­for­mance

Under­stand­ing the root caus­es is essen­tial for DST risk man­age­ment.

1. Ten­ant Vacan­cies or Defaults

The most com­mon cause of under­per­for­mance is income dis­rup­tion. There are DST that rely on mul­ti­ple leas­es from many ten­ants. This is in con­trast to a triple net (NNN) lease to one spe­cif­ic ten­ant. Even in an offer­ing that has a few ten­ants in a port­fo­lio, ten­ants may vacate. Leas­es may not renew and ten­ants may default or declare bank­rupt­cy. This is espe­cial­ly impact­ful for a sin­gle-ten­ant, retail, and office prop­er­ties DSTs.

Impact: Reduced rental income → low­er dis­tri­b­u­tions

2. Mar­ket Down­turns

Real estate mar­kets are cycli­cal. There are many poten­tial fac­tors such as declin­ing local demand with increased sup­ply. This may have been the sin­gle rea­son that many loca­tions expe­ri­enced pres­sure on rates.  In addi­tion, ris­ing inter­est rates (not on the under­ly­ing loans) but over­all stress on the mar­ket.  Any eco­nom­ic reces­sion with job loss or elim­i­na­tion of local indus­try may cause dis­rup­tion, espe­cial­ly in the mul­ti­fam­i­ly mar­kets. Even strong prop­er­ties can suf­fer dur­ing down­turns.

Exam­ple:
A mul­ti­fam­i­ly DST in a boom­ing mar­ket may strug­gle if job growth slows. The 2026 mar­ket out­look does have some opti­mistic out­look.

Inter­nal Link:
2026 DST Mar­ket Out­look ~ What Investors Should Expect This Year — DST Edu­ca­tion and Mar­ket News

3. Poor Prop­er­ty Man­age­ment

Since DST investors are pas­sive, per­for­mance depends heav­i­ly on man­age­ment qual­i­ty.  We have com­ment­ed in past writ­ing that the deci­sion on local prop­er­ty man­age­ment or nation­al is a spon­sor deci­sion to make.  Spon­sors need to be in a posi­tion to change man­age­ment, when need be, to pro­tect the asset. Issues may include inef­fi­cient oper­a­tions, poor ten­ant reten­tion, ris­ing expens­es (or atten­tion to keep­ing expens­es under con­trol).  Over­all fail­ure to adapt to mar­ket changes will have an affect on the over­all health of the asset.  The Impact: Reduced Net Oper­at­ing income (NOI)

Inter­nal Link:
Investors Doing their §1031/DST Research Overview ~ Part Three Spon­sor Respon­si­bil­i­ty — DST Edu­ca­tion and Mar­ket News

4. Over-Lever­age or High Debt Ser­vice

By design many DST have non-recourse financ­ing. How­ev­er, exces­sive debt can ampli­fy prob­lems. High loan pay­ments reduce flex­i­bil­i­ty. Ris­ing inter­est rates may not affect the DST dur­ing the course of own­er­ship. How­ev­er, when the loan moves form inter­est only to an amor­tized loan (many loans remain ‘inter­est only’) can increase over­all debt ser­vice although reduc­ing the prin­ci­ple bal­ance and build­ing equi­ty. Impact: Less income avail­able for dis­tri­b­u­tions

What Hap­pens to Investors When a DST Under­per­forms?

Let’s address the most impor­tant ques­tion: what if a DST los­es val­ue or under­per­forms?

1. Reduced Cash Flow

The first impact is usu­al­ly low­er income. Dis­tri­b­u­tions may drop below pro­jec­tions Pay­ments may become incon­sis­tent.

2. Dis­tri­b­u­tion Delays or Sus­pen­sions

In more severe cas­es: Dis­tri­b­u­tions may be tem­porar­i­ly paused Cash may be redi­rect­ed to cov­er expens­es or debt.

This is often referred to as a DST dis­tri­b­u­tion short­fall explained.

3. Longer Hold Peri­od

If mar­ket con­di­tions are unfa­vor­able: The spon­sor may delay sell­ing the prop­er­ty Hold peri­od may extend beyond orig­i­nal pro­jec­tions.

4. Low­er Sale Pro­ceeds

At exit, the prop­er­ty may sell for less than expect­ed.

Impact: Reduced over­all return Poten­tial loss of prin­ci­pal (in extreme cas­es)

5. Lim­it­ed Investor Con­trol

One of the key chal­lenges in how to han­dle DST under­per­for­mance is that investors have no direct con­trol. You can­not sell ear­ly You can­not change man­age­ment You rely on the sponsor’s deci­sions.

Can a DST Recov­er from Under­per­for­mance?

Yes—many DSTs expe­ri­ence tem­po­rary set­backs and recov­er. The recov­ery depends on a few key fac­tors such as the over­all mar­ket rebound, lease renewals or new ten­ants, and effec­tive man­age­ment. Real estate is a long-term invest­ment, and short-term under­per­for­mance does not always lead to per­ma­nent loss. Each asset class my have a dif­fer­ent lev­el of resilien­cy.

How to Mit­i­gate DST Under­per­for­mance Risk

Smart investors focus on pre­ven­tion. As a reminder, DST are for accred­it­ed investors only.

1. Diver­si­fy Across Mul­ti­ple DSTs

After review­ing investor suit­abil­i­ty, we dis­cuss with investors the diver­si­fi­ca­tion strat­e­gy that DST affords to investor. The sug­ges­tion is to Avoid putting all your cap­i­tal into one invest­ment. Even with $500,000 an investor can diver­si­fy across sev­er­al DST since many ini­tial invest­ments are typ­i­cal­ly $100,000. Instead: Allo­cate across dif­fer­ent prop­er­ties Invest in mul­ti­ple mar­kets Use var­ied asset types.  We do have sev­er­al investors who only was a sin­gle asset in their port­fo­lio.  We have devel­oped an appli­ca­tion free to all investors called my alts data.  This enables an investor to see all their alter­na­tive invest­ments (as well as oth­er invest­ments) in one place.

Inter­nal Link:
What does DST Diver­si­fi­ca­tion Cost? Part 1 — DST Edu­ca­tion and Mar­ket News

2. Choose Expe­ri­enced Spon­sors

Strong spon­sors can nav­i­gate down­turns and seek to main­tain occu­pan­cy. The abil­i­ty to con­trol costs will be an ongo­ing con­cern as we have seen across the board increased insur­ance and oth­er unfore­seen cost ris­es. This is one of the most impor­tant fac­tors in mit­i­gat­ing DST invest­ment risk.

3. Ana­lyze Ten­ant and Lease Qual­i­ty

In the indus­tri­al and non-res­i­den­tial sec­tors look for long-term leas­es. Hav­ing cred­it­wor­thy ten­ants is a plus along with a diver­si­fied ten­ant base.

4. Review Debt Struc­ture Care­ful­ly

Cer­tain investors are forced into a more con­ser­v­a­tive financ­ing (trans­la­tion low­er LTV). This is dri­ven by the spon­sors reduc­ing the LTV (increas­ing more equi­ty in assets).  Yes, this reduces risk. There is also an increase in the num­ber of all-cash DST offer­ings when com­pared to three years ago, espe­cial­ly with the increase in bor­row­ing inter­est rate. A few years ago, there was a on mod­er­ate lever­age (50–65% LTV) which is now 40%-50% on aver­age. This cre­ates a chal­lenge when bal­anc­ing the debt replace­ment for cer­tain 1031 exchange investors.  Our bal­anc­ing spread­sheets help with bal­anc­ing the exchange to avoid adding fresh cash.  There are all cash investors who will move into a lever­aged DST for oth­er tax effi­cien­cies.

5. Set Real­is­tic Expec­ta­tions

Pro­jec­tions are not guar­an­teed and are just that, pro­jec­tions. Pru­dent advi­sors and investors should plan for: mar­ket fluc­tu­a­tions, Tem­po­rary income drops and poten­tial longer hold peri­ods.

There are a few Com­mon Investor Mis­takes to avoid when eval­u­at­ing DSTs.

Assum­ing Pro­jec­tions Are Guar­an­teed- All fore­casts are estimates—not promis­es.

Ignor­ing Risk Fac­tors- Every DST car­ries expo­sure to mar­ket and oper­a­tional risks.

Over­con­cen­tra­tion- Invest­ing too heav­i­ly in one prop­er­ty or spon­sor.

Chas­ing Yield- High­er yields often come with high­er risk.

Final Thoughts: Prepar­ing for the Real­i­ty of DST Invest­ing

DSTs are designed to sim­pli­fy real estate investing—but they are not risk-free.

Under­stand­ing DST under­per­for­mance helps you stay pre­pared and make bet­ter deci­sions. In the heat of the moment avoid emo­tion­al reac­tions dur­ing down­turns.

The most suc­cess­ful investors will eval­u­ate diver­si­fy­ing strate­gi­cal­ly and select­ing strong spon­sors. WE attempt to focus on long-term per­for­mance.

By approach­ing DST invest­ing with dis­ci­pline and real­is­tic expec­ta­tions, you can bet­ter nav­i­gate chal­lenges and posi­tion your­self for more con­sis­tent out­comes.

DSTs are not for all investors.  The acqui­si­tion of a DST is for accred­it­ed investors only.  Con­tact your invest­ment advis­er for addi­tion­al details on how a DST may be a solu­tion to your §1031 Exchange and suit­ed for your invest­ment future. For more infor­ma­tion on how to prop­er­ly set up an IRC §1031Tax Deferred Exchange or if you are an accred­it­ed investor and would like addi­tion­al infor­ma­tion on a DST con­tact Al DiNi­co­la at 239–691-8098 or email adinicola@Fiduciarycm.com.

Advi­so­ry and Con­sult­ing Ser­vices offered through FIDUCIARY CM^® (Fidu­cia­ry Cap­i­tal Man­age­ment LLC). FIDUCIARY CM^® is an SEC Reg­is­tered Invest­ment Advis­er. Infor­ma­tion pre­sent­ed is for edu­ca­tion­al pur­pos­es only for a broad audi­ence. The infor­ma­tion does not intend to make an offer or solic­i­ta­tion for the sale or pur­chase of any spe­cif­ic secu­ri­ties, invest­ments, or invest­ment strate­gies. Invest­ments involve risk and are not guar­an­teed. FIDUCIARY CM^® has rea­son­able belief that this mar­ket­ing does not include any false or mate­r­i­al mis­lead­ing state­ments or omis­sions of facts regard­ing ser­vices, invest­ment, or client expe­ri­ence. Please refer to our Firm Brochure (ADV2) for mate­r­i­al risks dis­clo­sures. The opin­ions referred to are as of the date of pub­li­ca­tion and are sub­ject to change due to changes in the mar­ket or eco­nom­ic con­di­tions and may not nec­es­sar­i­ly come to pass. FIDUCIARY CM^® may dis­cuss and dis­play charts, graphs, for­mu­las, and stock picks which are not intend­ed to be used by them­selves to deter­mine which secu­ri­ties to buy or sell, or when to buy or sell them. Con­sul­ta­tion with a licensed finan­cial pro­fes­sion­al is strong­ly sug­gest­ed. Please remem­ber that secu­ri­ties can­not be pur­chased, sold, or trad­ed via e‑mail or voice mes­sage sys­tem. For more infor­ma­tion, please vis­it www.FiduciaryCM.com  Secu­ri­ties may be offered through MSC-BD, LLC. Mem­ber of FINRA / SIPC.