Site icon DST Education ~ Market Intelligence

How Much of My $100,000 Investment Actually Buys Real Estate? | Article 3 of 14

DST Due Dili­gence Lab  •  How I Look at a Trans­ac­tion 

By Al DiNi­co­la, AIF®
VP, Invest­ment Prop­er­ty Wealth Man­age­ment®
Real­ized Finan­cial, Inc
Co-author, DST Wealth Build­ing
Edi­tor, DSTNews.org

This is one of the ques­tions I hear in dif­fer­ent forms: ‘I am invest­ing $100,000. Does that mean I own $100,000 of real estate?’ My response is that we need to dis­tin­guish equi­ty, gross real estate expo­sure and the costs of putting the invest­ment togeth­er.

Calculate the investor’s fraction

In Har­bor Point, $100,000 divid­ed by $23 mil­lion of total investor equi­ty equals about 0.4348% of the investor equi­ty. Apply­ing that per­cent­age to the $40 mil­lion prop­er­ty cost pro­duces about $173,913 of gross pur­chase-price expo­sure. That may sur­prise some­one who thinks a $100,000 cash con­tri­bu­tion must cor­re­spond to exact­ly $100,000 of gross real estate.

Bring debt into the picture

The same illus­tra­tive per­cent­age applied to $20 mil­lion of mort­gage prin­ci­pal equals about $86,957 of financ­ing expo­sure. Sub­tract that from the $173,913 gross prop­er­ty-cost expo­sure and the remain­ing equi­ty-fund­ed share of the pur­chase price is approx­i­mate­ly $86,956. These fig­ures are eco­nom­ic allo­ca­tions for our teach­ing exam­ple, not a rep­re­sen­ta­tion that investors direct­ly hold apart­ment titles or per­son­al­ly owe that loan.

Follow the rest of the contribution

Approx­i­mate­ly $8,696 of the $100,000 is attrib­ut­able to the investor’s pro­por­tion­al share of the $2 mil­lion expense pool, and about $4,348 to the $1 mil­lion reserve pool. In round num­bers: about $86,956 sup­ports the pur­chase-price equi­ty, $8,696 sup­ports trans­ac­tion costs and $4,348 sup­ports ini­tial reserves. The total is $100,000, allow­ing for round­ing. Reserves remain trust assets; trans­ac­tion costs need to be ana­lyzed by type.

Do not turn an allocation into a tax conclusion

Some investors ask whether the $86,957 debt allo­ca­tion solves a 1031 exchange debt-replace­ment require­ment. It may be tempt­ing to assume it does, but I would not make that leap. Tax lia­bil­i­ties, debt relief and exchange pro­ceeds have their own rules. An investor’s qual­i­fied inter­me­di­ary and tax coun­sel should deter­mine the actu­al exchange impli­ca­tions based on the final doc­u­ments.

Al’s due diligence perspective

I like to ask a spon­sor for a one-page investor-lev­el rec­on­cil­i­a­tion using my actu­al pro­posed invest­ment amount. If the trans­ac­tion makes sense only when gross prop­er­ty expo­sure is pre­sent­ed with­out costs or debt, I want a clos­er look.

Next: Arti­cle 4 — Under­stand­ing the DST Fee Stack

Impor­tant Dis­clo­sures: This mate­r­i­al is for infor­ma­tion­al pur­pos­es only and does not con­sti­tute an offer to sell or solic­i­ta­tion to pur­chase secu­ri­ties. DST invest­ments involve risks, includ­ing lim­it­ed liq­uid­i­ty, loss of prin­ci­pal, and non-guar­an­teed dis­tri­b­u­tions. Investors should con­sult their tax, legal, and finan­cial advis­ers. Invest­ment advi­so­ry ser­vices offered through Fidu­cia­ry Cap­i­tal Man­age­ment LLC, an SEC-reg­is­tered invest­ment advis­er. Secu­ri­ties offered through Real­ized Finan­cial, Inc., Mem­ber FINRA/SIPC. Fidu­cia­ry Cap­i­tal Man­age­ment is a sep­a­rate reg­is­tered invest­ment advi­so­ry firm and is not a sub­sidiary of Real­ized Finan­cial, Inc., or Real­ized.

Exit mobile version